Get the sweet hit without the sugar: How to swap squash, cola and sugary drinks for water

Published: 5 min read
Mint green air up bottle in a bike basket next to a punnet of fresh strawberries

The easiest way to swap sugary drinks for water is to change a single, specific drink in your day, and keep what you love about it: the cold, the fizz or the flavour. Here's how to make the swap stick.

The four things that make sugary drinks feel exciting

Picture the 3pm can: the cold in your hand, the hiss as it opens, the first fizzy sip, and the five-minute break that comes with it.

That's four separate pleasures: cold, fizz, flavour and a ritual. Sugar is only part of the flavour.

  • Cold

  • Fizz

  • Flavour

  • Ritual

Sugar is only part of the flavour.

You don't reach for it because you're thirsty. You reach for it because it's 3pm, you've just sat down, and the fridge is right there. Those are cues, and cues can be reassigned: same moment, different drink.

Most swaps fail because water gets none of the four. A lukewarm glass at your desk loses on every count, so it never feels like a fair trade. Swap one drink, and give water back the parts you actually miss.

Zero sugar is a good first step, not the finish line

Zero sugar versions keep the cold, the fizz and the sweet taste, which is why they work as a first move. The NHS lists sugar-free drinks among its swaps, and for someone on a can a day, the sugar drops fast.

But the label says less than you'd think. "Zero sugar" describes sugar only, so the drink can still carry calories from other ingredients, and "no added sugar" can include sugars from fruit juice. The sweetness usually comes from non-sugar sweeteners such as aspartame or sucralose.

Add the aftertaste some people notice, and it can feel like a choice between sugar and sweeteners. There's a third option: flavoured water, still or sparkling, with nothing to check on the label.

Rebuild your habit, one thing at a time

Start with the one drink you'd miss least. A 330 ml can of cola has around 35g of sugar (opens in a new tab), and NHS guidance for adults is no more than 30g of free sugars a day (opens in a new tab).

Swap a daily can and you skip roughly 1 kg of sugar a month (35g × 30 days). That's a small win to be proud of, from a single change.

A 330 ml can of cola has around 35g of sugar, more than the NHS guidance for adults of no more than 30g of free sugars a day. Swap a daily can and you skip roughly 1 kg of sugar a month.

Keep the cold

Fill a tall glass with ice before you pour anything. Cold is half the appeal of a can, and the ice slows you down enough to enjoy it. A jug in the fridge keeps the cold option one pour away, and a bottle filled with ice goes with you when you leave the house.

Keep the fizz

If cola is your drink, sparkling water is the closest swap: the same bubbles, no sugar. If plain bubbles feel harsh at first, start half sparkling and half still. Still or sparkling, it's your call.

Bring the flavour back

Flavours beyond just fruit work best: cucumber and mint, ginger and lime, or rosemary with a slice of orange. Herbs and natural ingredients give you taste with nothing to check on the label. Slice thinly so it infuses faster, and make a jug the night before. Cold herbal or fruit tea over ice, unsweetened, is another easy way to get flavour without sugar.

Keep the ritual

The 3pm can was never just about the drink. It was the break. Keep the break: same time, same glass, five minutes away from the screen. If you work from home, step into another room; if you're in an office, take the bottle to the window.

Turn the sweetness down slowly

If squash is your drink, make it a little weaker each week. If you pour about 50 ml, try 40 ml this week and 30 ml the next. Before long it's a hint of flavour in cold water, and you've arrived at flavoured water without noticing.

Sweetness is the hardest part to replace, so don't expect to match it on day one. Herbs, cucumber and citrus give a gentler, fresher taste, and the aim is to enjoy that for what it is, not to copy a can.

Syrup, squash, zero-sugar fizzy drinks or flavoured water?

SugarSweetenersSweet hitBest for
SyrupTypically highUsually noneStrongAn occasional treat
SquashVaries by brand and dilutionIn "no added sugar" versionsMediumStepping down gradually
Zero-sugar fizzy drinksNoneYesStrongA first step
Flavoured waterNone, or a trace from fruitNoneGentleEveryday drinking

Recipes vary by brand, so check the label on anything bottled.

FAQs

Not really. Unsweetened juice still counts towards free sugars, and the NHS suggests keeping it to 150 ml a day. A splash in sparkling water is a lighter way to enjoy the taste.